Innovate or Perish! Innovative Learning Techniques for Indian Retail
By ripul |Apr17, 2007 Main Articles Add commentsI would be a fool to reiterate that India is going though a revolution in retail. Indian giants like Reliance, Godrej, ITC, Bharati, Tata, RPG, and others have committed billions of rupees in setting up stores, running them, supply chain, etc. Every conceivable type of store is being planned and every product will be for sale — Indian shopping habits would not be the same again.
In this mad rush to the market, they forget to see the impending danger! Where are the trained people to run all these fancy stores? Some would say that India produces huge number of undergraduates and they can man the stores, can’t they? I would say, yes and umm no! Yes, they are literate, but are they really educated? Do they have sound understanding about operations to man a store? Do they have basic communication skills to communicate with peers, supervisors, or customers?
With no schools in India training in retail and therefore unavailable trained manpower, the retailers have no choice but to have extensive in-house training programs. Do you think that they will be able to have trained manpower for all the stores? I don’t think it will be possible with the current state of classroom training. They would need to think out of the box to deliver great and timely training to all — classroom training will be grossly inadequate. So how does retail learn? How will retail in India perform?
The answers should be pragmatic and innovative. However, the answers are difficult as retail works from early morning to late night — some even work round the clock. People in retail are hungry for vertical growth — they are ready to put in late hours (and they do!) — they have no time to learn. The answers are difficult as many in-shop retail people are not educated — many of them have not completed their schooling while many others struggle with English, Hindi or the regional language. The answers are difficult as the things that people sell are new to them, they come from backgrounds where they either could not afford these or did not know such things existed — people are not familiar with the products they sell. The answers are difficult as organizations would rather put people to work than put them in training as “some untrained hands are better than no hands on the floor” and they convince themselves — “they will learn on the floor.”
So the big question is how do you train such a huge number of people in retail skills?
The answer is that they can be trained using multiple media and out of the box thinking about training. If Indian retail giants continue to use only classroom training, they are doomed.
The media that can be used to train depends upon many characteristics of the learners — education, time for training, type of training, organizational hierarchy, family background, economic background, age, gender, etc. The media does not depend on whims and fancies of VP Retail.
Let’s understand media that can be used for shop floor people — people who ensure that things run properly on the floor. They man the shop helping customers find and choose the right product, ensure that aisles are clear, ensure that merchandise is properly displayed, ensure that merchandise is never finished, man the cash register, etc. This kind of job does require basic education and skills. As these people are required all the time to run the store - from early morning to late night, they do not have time for structured learning in the classroom. So we need to use media to bring the classroom to them.
a. Audio training: Each retail store usually has a public address system or a CD/Cassette player that runs background music for customers. Now there are times when customers are not there — early morning while cleaning and maintenance is going on or late evening when floor people are winding up to close to the store. At this time, audio training sessions can be run in the public address system. These audio sessions could ideally teach a new language, customer handling skills, grooming skills, or organizational policies and values. Ideally these are short nuggets of 2-3 minutes each and many of such nuggets must run daily. They must be repeated periodically. This repeated learning will increase retention and greater recall.
b. Video training: Many stores do have TVs that run advertisements in the store. Retail chains use these very effectively to train about how to use products, training for new products, arranging products on the shelf, cleaning, appearance, etc. These are 5-10 minute sessions that people take in small groups once a day. These training run during lunch or scheduled breaks.
c. SMS training: Hard to believe but true — most low paid shop floor people do own a mobile phone. Retailers use SMS as a very powerful way to learn in extremely short messages. The short messages teach about today’s deals and things that are very dynamic.
d. Flash Cards: Written word and pictures are a powerful medium of instruction. Flash cards can be distributed to all people in the morning and rotated the next day. Each flash card can have one concept about the business. By doing this, each person can learn about one aspect of the business in a day and in some months many concepts are clear.
f. Sales Terminals: Point of sales terminals are effectively changed to ensure that they can be used for product learning. This learning can happen as people are punching in orders. A small nugget about what the punched product does or what can be made out of it or how it works can enhance the knowledge of the learner. This positively affects business in the short term.
And yes, retailers can use classroom training for mid- and senior-level managers. eLearning is also a very effective tool for mid-level managers or shop supervisors.
A combination of the above techniques can ensure that retail organizations are learning and thus growing organizations. This will ensure low attrition and high morale of employees. Most importantly, this will ensure a more informed and efficient set of employees to man these fancy stores and consequently offer far better customer experience.
This post has been viewed 43 times.






17th April, 2007 at 6:45 am
Great insights! I completely agree with you. Salespeople are not equipped to man the stores but are expected to meet their targets and close deals. Typically, stress is on product knowledge while there are so many other areas also. Imagine talking to a salesperson who knows all he needs to know about a product but is extremely blunt or rude. Would the customer buy the product? I don’t think so.
These training areas need to be identified and the solutions need to be suggested accordingly. Only if the management believes in the value of training, will they ensure that it happens systematically. Then, salespeople will also take training programs seriously.
17th April, 2007 at 6:58 am
Apart from the management, I would also attribute responsibility to the training consulting company and the training manager. These people just cannot convince the management about the clear return on training — as they themselves are not clear what value training can offer.
Training managers and consultancies must be able to clearly evolve metrics to evaluate effectiveness of learning as well as measure the returns in money terms. Only then they will be able to convince a clear management buy in.
17th April, 2007 at 7:01 am
What I really liked about this article is that it suggests multiple learning solutions. Several organizations believe in investing only in classroom training or just an e-module. Learning solutions should be decided based on the learner profile. Learning should be continuous and should be reinforced. It cannot happen in isolation. The management has to play its role too.
17th April, 2007 at 7:07 am
Fundoo ideas! Completely agree with the need for some out-of-the-box thinking. Typically training is restricted to classroom, elearning, on the job or a blend of these three. But as mentioned by Ripul, learning can happen in various other ways.
“Learning” is more important than the methods used. Intelligent learning solutions can pave the way for numerous such client and domain specific revolutionary solutions.
17th April, 2007 at 7:09 am
That’s right. Training consultancies take the easy way out. As you mentioned, they must be able to show value to the management. How many training consultancies can show results? They must put an end to rolling out one hour training programs that do do nothing but waste the learner’s time and the management’s money.
17th April, 2007 at 7:21 am
I think training consultancies and training managers never could understand and thus quantify the value of training. In the process, they could never tell the management about it. Now, after many years of incompetency, the management believes that training is an extra thing — it may or may not bring any results — its just to keep people happy. They do not see training as a business enhancer.
How do you propose to break this myth? Or how do you propose to ensure that return on learning can be quantified?
17th April, 2007 at 7:49 am
1. Training needs analysis must be done to ensure that the training needs are identified.
2. Learner observation and analysis is done.
3. Requirements are documented.
4. Evaluation metrics and learning objective are designed. Consultants should very clearly show what kind of difference their intervention will make. Here, the role that management needs to play to ensure that learning is reinforced is also very clearly stated.
5. Learning solutions are decided based on the all the above. A pilot is created.
6. Learner testing is done to check the bugs and obstacles in the pilot.
7. Evaluation of the course takes place. Observe whether all the outcomes promised in the evaluation metrics were met.
When you can prove that your course is effective, you will get a 100% buy in from the management. Training will bring about the required change and there is proof for all to see. This should show the value in training.
24th February, 2010 at 2:00 pm
I am very happy I found your blog on bing. Thank you for the sensible critique. Me and my friend were just preparing to do some research about this. I am glad to see such reliable information being shared for free out there.
Regards,
Akram from Atlanta city
24th July, 2010 at 1:52 pm
Good job dude! You deserve it!
24th July, 2010 at 2:16 pm
Really nice blog! Keep it coming!